|
|
Does
changing your language change your thought?My language as in my manner of
speech or my language as in whether I'm talking in French or English, or what? My manner
of speech reflects the way my thoughts are going. If you switch between French and English
there are some things you have to do differently, thought-wise. For instance, I was
translating a French poem and couldn't figure out how to do the line breaks properly,
since the word order was different from the way it would be put in English. Like
adjectives coming after nouns instead of being before them.
Karen, 21
Marshelltown/Ames, IA USA
I have heard that changing the language in
which you think changes the structure and nature of your thoughts. I speak only English
and cannot verify this idea.
Jill, 60
Saylorsburg, PA USA
Weird question. I'll pass.
Fisch, 45
Preston, CT
USA
I don't think it would, but I wouldn't
really know since I haven't ever completely changed my language before. I know french but
the only time I speak it is in french class so...?
Dianne, 16
Oshawa, Ontario CANADA
This is Foucault's whole argument
isn't it? That we live inside language and can only perceive a world to the extent that we
have the language to describe it. I have to agree with
this Just like if you don't have the ability to name an emotion lilke anger your doomed to
never fully understand it. Or think of the Eskimos who have multiple names for snow to
detail the substance in variable conditions. Don't you think they have a broader range of
understanding of their environment than others who simply see snow.
Felicia, 35
Lowell, MA
USA
Not for
me.
Laura, 36
Lowell, MA
USA
'm not sure. I would think that to learn a
language and then speak it, you would have to think in that language when using it.
Jeremy, 14
Highlands Ranch, CO USA
I'm not sure if I get the
question, if you mean changing from English to Spanish or something I can't relate to
that. If you mean changing from a formal to an informal dialogue, then I wouldn't say the
thoughts themselves change, just the level of honesty or the amount of information given.
Alias Irrelevante
I would have thought so, but the
church I belongs to sends missionaries all over the
world but first they get a crash course in that country's language. During the training
period, they are not allowed to speak English - all their communications must be in their
"new" language. They soon become very proficient in that language and when they
are overseas they are able to debate with priests, ministers, etc. if they have to. My
husband served in
Southern France for two years and he said
that for a long time he dreamt in French, and many other ex-missionaries I have spoken to
have said the same thing. This leads me to believe that a change in language DOES lead to
a change in thought.
Reba, 51
Rockville, MD
USA
I don't understand the question. Do you mean
when I speak another language, do I then think in that language? I'm confused.
etoile , 20
Washington, DC USA
Not for me, personally. I speak two
languages fluently and I don't seem to think any different whichever one I'm speaking.
Shanna, 16
Cardiff ENGLAND
Neurolinguists would affirm this.
Jane, 60
West Linn, OR
USA
Changing my language changes the
thoughts of my child and of the children I teach. As
they hear me use more tolerant language (accompanied by tolerant behavior and action),
they learn tolerance through observation. And yes, I think over time, the use of more
tolerant language can build tolerance in ourselves - but it is a much slower process than
with the young.
Deb
I don't think that changing one's language
changes one's train of thought. How a person thinks cannot be changed due to a different
language. It might affect it somewhat but that's it.
Patti, 44
PA USA
This is a very broad question.
It could mean 'change your speaking
language'.For example, becoming multi-lingual may mean you have to change your
thought patterns toexpress your self clearly to the listener.
It could mean the language you might use to
express your thoughts clearly as you speak, in which case, do you mean to change your
language to clearly express what your are thinking at the moment?
It could also mean that if you are writing,
do you need to change your language to clearly mean what your thoughts are on paper to the
reader?
And finally, you could also ask, 'If you are
having a bad day and you are feeling negative about the world, does changing your language
change your outlook (thoughts)?
Rich, 52
Lowell, MA
USA
Duh...I aint no nothin' 'bout
nothin'
Frodo
age runknown, parts unknown
It can, but usually doesn't. It depends on
your reasoning. It can also be said that it is changing your thought that changes your
language. It's kind of one of those chicken/egg delimmas.
Firelady, 23
Dallas, TX
USA
Yesterday /
Tomorrow |